There is a bit of a judgment call to make - will the bees make enough honey for them to winter on AND make you a surplus to harvest? For first year bees I tend to let them keep whatever they make and I'll do some supplemental feeding too. For bees that have made it through the winter I expect them to make a surplus. However if they are light (using September 15 here as the end of the fall flow in a typical year) I'll feed them as well. You'll often hear it said that it is easier to feed bees in the fall than in February.
I winter with 2 deeps and a medium. I'm trying to promote large clusters of young bees going into winter. If the queen is competing for space with the storage of winter feed, then that cluster won't be as large. Of course the whole process starts at this time of the year with proper supering...which helps prevent the broodnest from becoming honey bound.
Also, that extra honey left on the colony will be turned into bees the following spring.
A forum community dedicated to beekeeping, bee owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about breeding, honey production, health, behavior, hives, housing, adopting, care, classifieds, and more!