my first year I ordered italians through a local beek who gets them from a supplier who travels south to get 5 frame nucs to sell in my state. They were a miserable disaster, very weak, nasty temperament, never really built up, no honey, and 1 of two died off in the first winter. The beek I got them from said his were the same way, and he'd never had that problem before from that supplier. He said they were more like 3 frame nucs and wasn't even sure if he had queens in some of his. He was going to try to get a partial refund, although I never saw any money come back my way. Hmmmm.
Last spring I ordered an 8 frame single with a MN Hygienic Queen from an outfit down by LaCrosse, WI to replace the one that died off. Rather than shipping I drove the 8+hour round trip to go pick them up. The difference in price was about $30 plus my time but what a HUGE DIFFERENCE in quality! Immediate build up, lots of honey and relatively docile for most of the summer, very strong going into winter.
cdykstra