Grafting
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Nope. Feed cell builders and breeder queen hives Caspian solution. The larvae are swimming in jelly. No need to prime or any advantage I could see. As is there is some leftover jelly that the developing queen does not eat. This is my sign that they got plenty of jelly during development.
Jean-Marc
Jean-Marc
Last year I found that priming with water, using a toothpick really improved my success %. This year my first couple graft bars I used water primer and had poor success (30%). Switched to dry cells, and the next graft had 75% success. What's the best solution? ... Wait till the dandilion flow.
Luke
Luke
Where do you get it? I've never heard of it till now. I did find a few other posts about it, but is it really that effective?
Luke
Joined
·
2,617 Posts
Not me. With a bag of Chinese grafting tools handy (so I can always find a good one)there is no need to prime.That is assuming the larvae are well fed, as they should be.Now I admit to occasionally coming up without the larvae, so use that gob of jelley to prime the next cup.But it isn't necessary.
I do have to use a magnifier for grafting nowadays.
I do have to use a magnifier for grafting nowadays.
Joined
·
1,010 Posts
Yes, slightly better acceptance rate and able to graft younger larvae. Most commercial operations do not prime cells as it is just an extra step. Miksa Honey Farms is one of the only commercial operations that I know of that still primes cells, but it gives them a few extra percentage points on their takes.
We were grafting between 1400-1800 cells every four days during queen production time. Each cell gets a prime. Much easier on the larvae in my opinion. You don't have to struggle getting it off the tool and risk Rollin it over. As for the caspian solution. We had two
Cell yards this season and as a control used the solution at one. My opinion, just another snake oil attempt. Put this amazing cure all solution into the hive and you'll have the strongest healthiest bees of the year. Give me a break.
Cell yards this season and as a control used the solution at one. My opinion, just another snake oil attempt. Put this amazing cure all solution into the hive and you'll have the strongest healthiest bees of the year. Give me a break.
I know I'm just small-time... this is my first year grafting. Using freshly hatched larvae, jzbz cups, chinese grafting tool, not priming cells (except for the occasional oops when I missed pulling a larvae out and got a 'tool' full of royal jelly, or screwed up putting it in the cell cup and pulled the larvae back out)...
All done in a 5-frame nuc, fed 1:1 sugar syrup, no protein supplement
Attempt 1 - grafted 28, got 25 (wasn't impressed with royal jelly production though, and cells looked small)
Attempt 2 - grafted 20, currently have 17 or more accepted, with plenty of royal jelly. This is using the same cell starter/finisher. I think the difference is all the capped brood I put in when doing attempt 1 has hatched and reached the ideal age for royal jelly production.
I try to be careful to keep the graft bars covered with a warm wet towel before and after the graft.
I use a magnifying headset... best deal I found was online through Tmart (http://www.tmart.com/Up-to-10X-Magn...fier-Lens-Visor-with-2-LED-Light_p142335.html)... shipped free to me, no duties/taxes.
I try to get the youngest larvae possible... working the outer ring of brood, on the edge between egg and larvae.
There are a ton of things that can affect acceptance... I'd love to do a couple studies on my own grafting, do a recording of my grafting to note my own comments on each cell as I go (touched the side of the cup, think I pinched the larvae, not sure if it rolled, that one looked perfect, preprimed that cell, larvae looks a little old)... and then check acceptance a few days later. Try to determine what human-influenced factors can affect acceptance. Taking the extra few seconds to redo a graft could mean an accepted queen cell, which in my opinion is more valuable than the time lost redoing it.
All done in a 5-frame nuc, fed 1:1 sugar syrup, no protein supplement
Attempt 1 - grafted 28, got 25 (wasn't impressed with royal jelly production though, and cells looked small)
Attempt 2 - grafted 20, currently have 17 or more accepted, with plenty of royal jelly. This is using the same cell starter/finisher. I think the difference is all the capped brood I put in when doing attempt 1 has hatched and reached the ideal age for royal jelly production.
I try to be careful to keep the graft bars covered with a warm wet towel before and after the graft.
I use a magnifying headset... best deal I found was online through Tmart (http://www.tmart.com/Up-to-10X-Magn...fier-Lens-Visor-with-2-LED-Light_p142335.html)... shipped free to me, no duties/taxes.
I try to get the youngest larvae possible... working the outer ring of brood, on the edge between egg and larvae.
There are a ton of things that can affect acceptance... I'd love to do a couple studies on my own grafting, do a recording of my grafting to note my own comments on each cell as I go (touched the side of the cup, think I pinched the larvae, not sure if it rolled, that one looked perfect, preprimed that cell, larvae looks a little old)... and then check acceptance a few days later. Try to determine what human-influenced factors can affect acceptance. Taking the extra few seconds to redo a graft could mean an accepted queen cell, which in my opinion is more valuable than the time lost redoing it.
Joined
·
1,010 Posts
Royal jelly, diluted with about 15-20% saline, just to make it flow a little easier through the dropper. Old research suggests royal jelly composition varies depending on the age of the larvae, so most of the royal jelly used for priming is removed shortly after the bees accept the cells.
This is my first year as well. I have not been fond of the Chinese grafting tool. how do you use them successfully? I use the metal Dental type tool and it works well for me. I have found if I leave a part of the larvae hanging off the edge of the tool, that it allows it to "grab" the bottom of the cup and slide right off. I don't prime, it makes it too slickery for the larvae, and I have to fight it to get it off the tool into the cup. But I am only getting 65-70 cells out of 100 for acceptance. with the Chinese tool I can't see the larvae as well and its more of a guess when I try and scoop it out, and then I seem to squish it while trying to use the plunger to slide it off.
Joined
·
2,617 Posts
[/QUOTE] Taking the extra few seconds to redo a graft could mean an accepted queen cell, which in my opinion is more valuable than the time lost redoing it.[/QUOTE]
Exactly right. If it doesn't seem right-redo it!
Exactly right. If it doesn't seem right-redo it!
Joined
·
86 Posts
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Join the discussion
Join now to ask and comment!