Beesource Beekeeping Forums banner

Does the inner cover go below or on top of the top feeder?

719 Views 21 Replies 5 Participants Last post by  drummerboy
I have my packages of bees in their hives, with top feeders in place. I have the top feeders on top of the inner cover currently. Is this correct? Or should it be the other way?

Thanks!
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
What kind of top feeder are you using? If it is the typical Mann Lake 4 gallon top feeder, you need to remove the inner cover. I think most top feeders would require the inner cover to be removed.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
Yes, the Mann Lake 4 gallon feeder. This one: Top Feeder with Painted Super
I have used those feeders for years. They should be placed directly on the top brood box. I remove the inner cover entirely, but you could place the inner cover on top of the feeder and then the telescoping cover on top of that. Obviously, the inner cover is not playing a role in the operation here, but you have it stored at the hive for when you remove the feeder. The reason I don't do that is because I think it makes it easier for the wind to blow the cover off.
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 3
Okay, thank you! Should I wait until I check the hives this Thursday to move it, or move it right away?
The bees will not be able to access the feeder to get the sugar if the inner cover is under it so you should remove it ASAP. Package bees will start dying very quick if no feed available.

I usually put the inner cover on top of the feeder and under the lid, just as an extra precaution against robbing, if the lid is a bit wonky.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
The bees will not be able to access the feeder to get the sugar if the inner cover is under it so you should remove it ASAP. Package bees will start dying very quick if no feed available.

I usually put the inner cover on top of the feeder and under the lid, just as an extra precaution against robbing, if the lid is a bit wonky.
There is a hole in the center of the inner covers I have. Like this one:



Shouldn't they be able to make it to the feeder through there? If need be, I'll switch them out after work tomorrow though.
See less See more
Oh, in that case bees could probably get up through the hole. You could take the lid off and see if bees are in the feeder insert.

BUT - I would still remove that inner cover from under the feeder. Reason being that entrance in the front, which will allow robber bees in to the feeder at a place where the package bees will not defend it. Which if it got bad could then lead to the whole hive coming under attack.

My advice, deal with it ASAP.
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 2
Makes sense. Thank you. I will make the change tonight after work.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I wasn't able to get to moving the inner cover two days ago, as my work schedule had me home after dark. However, I did put some painters tape over the outside opening to prevent robbing.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
2
However, I was able to fix it yesterday after work. I got all of the inner covers moved on all of the hives. I also did hive inspections on all of my five new hives. Three pound bee packages were put in the hive four days ago.

1. Italians - LOTS of activity. All ten frames had drawn comb, nectar, and pollen in many cells. Queen cage was empty. I was not able to find the queen. I did not see any eggs.

2. Saskatraz #1 - 8 of the 10 frames had drawn comb, with nectar and pollen in many cells. I was not able to find the queen. I did not see any eggs.

3. Saskatraz #2 - 6 of the 10 frames had drawn comb, with nectar and pollen in many cells. Maybe slightly less drawn comb. I was not able to find the queen. I did not see any eggs. There was some comb on the bottom of one of the frames:



4. Carniolan #1: Not many bees present. There was drawn comb on only one side of two frames. However, I was able to find the queen, and I actually saw her lay eggs (well, it looked that way to me; she was putting her abdomen into one of the cells). There were only bees covering one side of those two frames. Should I be worried about the small amount of bees in this hive?

5. Carniolan #2: Lots of bees present. There was drawn comb on 7 of the 10 frames, with lots of nectar, and some pollen in the cells. I saw the queen. I did not see eggs.



Overall, I'm pretty happy after four days as a complete newbee. However, the low number of bees in the first Carniolan hive does have me a bit concerned.

And is there any reason why there is comb being produced beneath the frames?
See less See more
There was drawn comb on only one side of two frames....... There were only bees covering one side of those two frames. Should I be worried about the small amount of bees in this hive?
Yes.

Sounds like this hive may be below the critical level needed to survive and grow. They may also be too small to access the syrup in the feeder, although maybe they will.

Something you can do is pick the whole hive up and swap places with one of the strong hives so they pick up some field bees. Then in a few weeks you can start feeding brood into them. Only give them one frame at a time, of brood that is point of hatch. They should not be given brood that will take a while till it hatches because they may struggle to look after it, only give them brood that will hatch straight away.
  • Helpful
  • Like
Reactions: 3
Yes.

Sounds like this hive may be below the critical level needed to survive and grow. They may also be too small to access the syrup in the feeder, although maybe they will.

Something you can do is pick the whole hive up and swap places with one of the strong hives so they pick up some field bees. Then in a few weeks you can start feeding brood into them. Only give them one frame at a time, of brood that is point of hatch. They should not be given brood that will take a while till it hatches because they may struggle to look after it, only give them brood that will hatch straight away.
There were a few getting syrup from the feeder fortunately, but not much comb made.

Thank you for the tips on increasing the worker bees. I'll swap places with my Italians tomorrow. I'm assuming during the heat of the day would be best when more are out foraging, to make the switch?
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Probably yes, although back when I was doing it commercially if we did that it just had to be whatever time we were there, seemed to work (y)
  • Like
Reactions: 1
So I checked on my hives again yesterday, about two and a half weeks after transferring the packages into their hives:

1. Italians - All ten frames had comb fully drawn, eggs, larvae, and lots of capped brood, and LOTS of bees. There were a couple of frames with several drone cells, but no queen cells. I didn't see the queen, but there were a ton of eggs. And these frames were HEAVY with nectar!

2. Saskatraz #1 - All ten frames had some drawn comb, with eight of them fully drawn. There were eggs, larvae, and capped brood. A lot of bees, but nothing like the Italians.

3. Saskatraz #2 - There were five frames with fully drawn comb, and at least some drawn comb on most all of them. There were eggs, larvae, and capped brood.

4. Carniolan #1: Still not many bees present. There was fully drawn comb on 2 frames, with one side of fully drawn comb on two other combs. There were eggs, larvae, and capped brood, and I saw the queen. There are just not many workers.

5. Carniolan #2: Comb was fully drawn on 6 of the frames, with partially drawn comb on the rest. There were eggs, larvae, and capped brood.

Few questions/concerns:

Being a newbee to beekeeping, I just realized I made a mistake. I bought ALL honey supers instead of more brood boxes. In order to give them more space, and to avoid swarming, I put a honey super on the first two boxes, to use as brood boxes. Will the honey super work as a brood box in the long term? And is there any harm in just using honey supers as brood boxes? I am off on Friday, so I can drive up to Mann Lake (about 30 minutes away) to pick up more brood boxes.

Also, I would like to add a frame of brood to hive #4, and possibly hive #3, from the first hive. Would taking two frames from one new hive be too much?
See less See more
take 1 frame from the biggest and give to the smallest. looks like 1 and 4
not open brood, emerging brood, or oldest brood. if it is not yet "old" then wait a bit
let the bees do their thing, 6 frames at this time is ok.
the more you mess around the more chance for an issue.

super on the first brood box is ok, once partially filled , lift and add the brood box under.


I put a honey super on the first two boxes,
the only hive needing box 2 is the Italian with 10 frames.
the other 3 should still be on the first box.
add second box at 9 frames drawn.
you do not add several at a time, until they are very strong.

only other thing to do maybe is pull frame 1 or 10 , when mostly full, from the Italians, shake the bees off to insure the queen is not present.
put it in one of the hives running behind in position 1 or 10.
these 2 frames will need to be filled for winter any way.
the stronger hive can assist in the draw and partial fill of winter stores frames for the weaker.

GG
See less See more
  • Like
  • Helpful
Reactions: 2
take 1 frame from the biggest and give to the smallest. looks like 1 and 4
not open brood, emerging brood, or oldest brood. if it is not yet "old" then wait a bit
let the bees do their thing, 6 frames at this time is ok.
the more you mess around the more chance for an issue.

super on the first brood box is ok, once partially filled , lift and add the brood box under.



the only hive needing box 2 is the Italian with 10 frames.
the other 3 should still be on the first box.
add second box at 9 frames drawn.
you do not add several at a time, until they are very strong.

only other thing to do maybe is pull frame 1 or 10 , when mostly full, from the Italians, shake the bees off to insure the queen is not present.
put it in one of the hives running behind in position 1 or 10.
these 2 frames will need to be filled for winter any way.
the stronger hive can assist in the draw and partial fill of winter stores frames for the weaker.

GG
Thank you for the quick reply.

Okay, looks like I jumped the gun a bit. At this point, should I remove the super I put on the second box when I get home from work tonight? Or just leave them now that I've already added them?

I'll buy more hive bodies on Friday, and make the switch from strongest to weakest.
Thank you for the quick reply.

Okay, looks like I jumped the gun a bit. At this point, should I remove the super I put on the second box when I get home from work tonight? Or just leave them now that I've already added them?

I'll buy more hive bodies on Friday, and make the switch from strongest to weakest.
I would then presume the super was the 3rd box.
if true then yes.

bees need the hive at a certain temperature and Humidity, to optimize brood rearing.
if 6 frames of bees are in a 2 deep + 1 medium setup, a lot of bees have to work on the environment, and less can draw comb or care for brood. Bees do better a little tight, higher bee density is better.
they will not die like they are but it is just less than optimal.

I use 5 ,8 and 10F
my splits/nucs/packages go from 5 to 8 when they need space, then to a 10 or a 5 over 5.
So I grow the space 2-5 frames ahead of the bees current progress.

IF mine,, the 5 and 6 and 8 frame hive would be in a 10F box only.
As the 9th frame is drawn I would add more space.
However IF you plan to head to the lake for 2 weeks THEN the situation is different, One must add enough space to last 2-3 weeks.

so the final answer depends on where the bees are (I have some 4 hours away),, how fast they are growing.
And how often you intend to check on them. and of course for you if you have the wooden ware in hand ;)

But I can offer the 6 frame hive should not be in 2 deeps and a medium.
Beside heating and humidity they need to patrol the space for intruders, like Wax moth, Small hive beetle , etc.

good luck
GG
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 1
When I checked on them yesterday, they were in just one deep. I then added a medium super to the first two. So they now have one deep plus one super only. I plan to buy new deeps on Friday to use as a second brood chambers moving forward.

They are about 1/4 mile from my house. I can check on them often.

Thank you!
  • Like
Reactions: 1
So I went back and looked into things a bit more, and I may have had some of my terminology wrong. I thought honey supers and medium brood boxes were different. I did not realize they were the exact same dimension boxes. So, I understand that two deep brood chambers is a 'standard' setup for brood, then supers on top. I guess I could stick with one super, then mediums on top. I guess I'd probably do 1 deep and then 2 mediums. Of course, that way, I'm having to inspect twice the number of frames... Though saving my back. I dunno...
  • Like
Reactions: 2
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Top