[edzkoda]

Other than the lifting considerations which seem to be the same arguments for going from deeps down to mediums, and for 10's down to 8's are there any other good reasons to not use 10 frame deep equipment?



Man, I'm 62, that's the only reason I need,lol

 

[GregB]

If you can not comfortably move the boxes around, what more reasons do you need?

One old beekeeper said:
"I made a lot of money. Then I spent all of it to fix my broken back and my warn-out knees."

That simple and yet sad - to keep repeating this.

 

[hockeyfan_019]

Actually I have been thinking about doing the same thing, but perhaps not for the same reasons. Certainly weight is a factor to consider, but here are some other points:

- 10f equipment is a bit more standardized, so things like excluders, feeders, etc are more common than 8f, and lower cost
- Using deeps for the brood boxes only, they shouldn't be terribly heavy, and they are not too high off the ground
- Honey supers mediums only
- If you have a jammin hive with 8f mediums, the height can be excessive. I already have the stand, bottom board, slatted rack, 4 supers in the brood nest, 1 honey super, feeder-waterer, ventilation board, and the roof. I can barely reach the top
- With 10f deeps, you only need 2 boxes for overwintering, instead of 3 mediums
- Since 10f boxes are wider, they will resist wind loads better. I have to use ratchet straps now, but I may feel better with a more stable stack
- When doing splits, I could use 2 frames from the deeps for walk-aways, but when I use mediums I normally use at least 3
- Taller narrower mating boxes may be a bit warmer, so the hive can manage the brood better. With mediums they need to spread out wider, so they can't cluster as well

I'll probably build some 10f equipment throughout the year and see how it goes. If nothing else Id like to use metal excluders instead of plastic, and they are much more common and affordable to get 10f versions.

 

[edzkoda]

Actually I have been thinking about doing the same thing, but perhaps not for the same reasons. Certainly weight is a factor to consider, but here are some other points:

- 10f equipment is a bit more standardized, so things like excluders, feeders, etc are more common than 8f, and lower cost
- Using deeps for the brood boxes only, they shouldn't be terribly heavy, and they are not too high off the ground
- Honey supers mediums only
- If you have a jammin hive with 8f mediums, the height can be excessive. I already have the stand, bottom board, slatted rack, 4 supers in the brood nest, 1 honey super, feeder-waterer, ventilation board, and the roof. I can barely reach the top
- With 10f deeps, you only need 2 boxes for overwintering, instead of 3 mediums
- Since 10f boxes are wider, they will resist wind loads better. I have to use ratchet straps now, but I may feel better with a more stable stack
- When doing splits, I could use 2 frames from the deeps for walk-aways, but when I use mediums I normally use at least 3
- Taller narrower mating boxes may be a bit warmer, so the hive can manage the brood better. With mediums they need to spread out wider, so they can't cluster as well

I'll probably build some 10f equipment throughout the year and see how it goes. If nothing else Id like to use metal excluders instead of plastic, and they are much more common and affordable to get 10f versions.

Im not seeing a big difference in price between 8 and 10, matter of fact I think more 8 frame equipment is being sold (catching on, not more than 10)

 

[calkal]

I think deeps make sense, I am running deeps for everything from brood chamber to honey supers. It allows for maximum flexibility and efficiency. They make tools to lift heavy things, and I plan to purchase one. An example is the Kaptarlift. https://youtu.be/pcSbmudGrwM

 

[odfrank]

After using 10 and 12 frame hives for 40 years I made a bunch of 8 frame. The 12 frames with Jumbo depth brood frames are a clear winner once again this year in reduced swarming leading to big crops. Brother Adam was right, Charlie B was wrong. Most of my hives are 10 frame to be in sink with local preferences.