|
Adrian
Wenner, Professor Emeritus (Natural History) at the University
of California, Santa Barbara, still continues research and writing
on the subject of bee biology, as well as several other topics.
He began his career with a 1940s stint as an electronics technician
in the U.S. Navy. While completing a mathematics degree in college,
he worked several years with honey bees under the mentorship
of his commercial beekeeping uncles, Clarence and Leo Wenner.
Adrian completed a new major
in biology at Chico State University and went on to the University
of Michigan for his doctorate. While there he was the first to
discover the sounds made by bees during their waggle dance and
pursued that lead for his dissertation. During later research,
while teaching at the University of California in Santa Barbara,
he and co-workers obtained experimental evidence sharply at variance
with expectations of the dance language hypothesis. They eventually
gained sufficient experimental evidence to conclude that a 1937
von Frisch hypothesis (that searching bees rely solely on odor
and not on some sort of "language") could better explain
honey bee recruitment to food crops --- as well as the means
by which swarms move.
Unfortunately, the publication
of the experimental results that countered the dance language
hypothesis generated intense hostility in the scientific community.
The adverse reaction of the bee research community made it no
longer possible for them to either publish in journals or to
reply in print to those who challenged their work. Adrian then
spent two decades in marine biological research while waiting
for tempers to cool. During that time he and Patrick Wells studied
the philosophy and sociology of science and published ANATOMY
OF A CONTROVERSY: THE QUESTION OF A "LANGUAGE" AMONG
BEES (Columbia University Press, 1990). That book documented
the fact that resistance to their research rested not as much
on evidence as on the training and attitude of scientists.
The notion of an odor-search
hypothesis (as originally postulated by von Frisch) now has a
broad following in the wider scientific community. |
| |
|
|
1A. |
READ
ME FIRST - A Chronology |
|
1B. |
SCIENCE ROUND-UP: The language of bees
Bee World - Summer, 1993 - Pages
91-98 |
|
1C. |
EXPERIMENTS ON DIRECTING BEE FLIGHT BY
ODORS
[Exerpts as published by von Frisch,
1943] |
| 2. |
ADRIAN WENNER RETIREMENT ANNOUNCEMENT
ABJ - April 1993 - Volume 133/No.
4 |
| 3. |
THE RELATIONSHIP OF SOUND PRODUCTION DURING
THE WAGGLE DANCE OF THE HONEY BEE TO THE DISTANCE OF THE FOOD
SOURCE.
Bull. Entomological Soc. of America. 5:142. 1959 Also included:
1961 Dissertation Abstract (Wenner). |
| 4. |
SOUND COMMUNICATION IN HONEY BEES.
Sci. Amer. 210:116-124. 1964 (Wenner) |
| 5. |
EXCURSUS SI from ANATOMY OF A CONTROVERSY: The
Question of a "Language" Among Bees.
Pages 353-361. 1990 (Wenner and Wells, Columbia Univ. Press) |
| 6. |
HONEY BEES: DO THEY USE THE DIRECTION INFORMATION
CONTAINED IN THEIR DANCE MANEUVER?
Science. 155:844-847. 1967 (Dennis Johnson) |
| 7. |
HONEY BEES: DO THEY USE THE DISTANCE INFORMATION
CONTAINED IN THEIR DANCE MANEUVER?
Science 155:847-849. 1967 (Wenner) |
| 8. |
HONEY BEE RECRUITMENT TO FOOD SOURCES: OLFACTION
OR LANGUAGE?
Science 164:84-86. 1969 (Wenner, Wells, and Johnson) |
| 9. |
DO HONEY BEES HAVE A LANGUAGE?
Nature 241:171-175. 1973 (Wells and Wenner) |
| 10. |
EXCURSUS EXC (Exchange with the Journal Science)
from ANATOMY OF A CONTROVERSY: The Question of a "Language"
Among Bees.
Pages 274-284. 1990 (Wenner and Wells, Columbia Univ. Press) |
| 11. |
THE
HONEY BEE DANCE LANGUAGE CONTROVERSY: THE SEARCH FOR "TRUTH"
VS THE SEARCH FOR USEFUL INFORMATION.
Am. Bee J. 127:130,131. 1987 (Wenner and Wells) |
| 12A. |
EFFICIENT
HUNTING OF FERAL COLONIES.
Bee Science 2:64-70. 1992 (Wenner, Alcock, and Meade) |
|
12B. |
A METHOD OF TRAINING BEES TO VISIT A FEEDING
STATION
Bee World - 42(1) : Pages 8 -
11 (1961) |
| 13. |
THE
HONEY BEES OF SANTA CRUZ ISLAND.
Bee Culture. 121(5):272-275. 1993 (Wenner and Thorp) |
| 14. |
SWARM
MOVEMENT: A MYSTERY EXPLAINED.
Am. Bee J. 132:27-31. Jan. 1992 (Wenner) |
| 15. |
RECRUITMENT,
SEARCH BEHAVIOR, AND FLIGHT RANGES OF HONEY BEES.
American Zoologist 31(6):768-782, 1991. (Wenner, Meade, and Friesen) |
| 16. |
FORAGING,
RECRUITMENT, AND SEARCH BEHAVIOR OF HONEY BEES
Am. Bee J. - October 1992 - Pages 641-644 (Ed Southwick) |
| 17. |
THE
HONEY BEE DANCE LANGUAGE CONTROVERSY
The Mankind Quarterly - Summer 1991 - Pages 357-365 (Subhash
Kak) |
| 18. |
2000
YEARS OF UNCERTAINTY
1 Oct. 1989 (Modified, May 1998) (Unpublished, Adrian M. Wenner)
(See also #19) |
| 19. |
HISTORY
AND STATUS OF THE TWO VON FRISCH RECRUITMENT HYPOTHESES.
Am. Bee J. - December 1992 - Volume 132:818 (Wenner) |
| 20. |
RECRUITMENT
TO FOOD: TANGIBLE ODOR-SEARCH OR MYSTICAL LANGUAGE?
Am. Bee J. - Volume 135 - December 1995 (Wenner) |
| 21. |
WHY
NOT GIVE ALL THE FACTS?
Bee Culture - Pages 551-552 - October, 1996 (Wenner) |
| 22. |
SCIENCE
AS A PROCESS: THE QUESTION OF BEE ''LANGUAGE" Bios.
Volume 64, Pages 78-83 - September 1993 - Number 3 (Wenner) |
| 23. |
IS
THE TOUTED "LANGUAGE" OF HONEY BEES REAL?
Adapted from Wenner, 1998. Pages 823-836 in Greenberg,
C. and M. Hara, (eds.), Comparative Psychology: A Handbook. Garland
Publishing, NY |
| 24. |
ODORS, WIND AND
COLONY FORAGING
Part I of Three Parts: The Need for
Odor
Am. Bee J., 138:746-748. October 1998. (Wenner). |
| 25. |
ODORS, WIND AND
COLONY FORAGING
Part II of Three Parts. The Role of
Wind Direction
Am. Bee J., 138:807-810. November 1998. (Wenner). |
| 26. |
ODORS, WIND AND
COLONY FORAGING
Part III of Three Parts: Insights from
Beehunting
Am. Bee J., 138:897-899. December 1998. (Wenner). |
| 27. |
A
NOTE ON THE DECISIVE "PROOF" FOR USE OF "DANCE
LANGUAGE".
Am. Bee J., 132:428-29. 1992. (Rosin) |
| 28. |
MORE
ON THE HONEY BEE "DANCE LANGUAGE" CONTROVERSY.
Am. Bee J., 132:499-500. 1992. (Rosin) |
| 29. |
DO
HONEY BEES STILL HAVE A "DANCE LANGUAGE"?
Am. Bee J., 139:577-578. 1999. (Rosin) |
|
30. |
BEE
"LANGUAGE" AGAIN?
Am. Bee J., Volume 140/No. 9.
September 2000 |
|
31. |
The
Role of Controversy in Animal Behavior
Comparative Psychology of Invertebrates,
1997 |
|
32. |
The
Elusive Honey Bee Dance "Language" Hypothesis
Journal of Insect Behavior, Vol.
15, No. 6, November 2002 - Pages 859-878 |
|
33. |
EXCURSUS NG (The Scent Gland (Nasanov Gland)
of Honey Bees) from ANATOMY OF A CONTROVERSY: The Question of
a "Language" Among Bees.
Pages 312-319. 1990 (Wenner and Wells, Columbia Univ. Press) |
|
34. |
DOES HONEY BEE NASANOV
PHEROMONE ATTRACT FORAGERS?
Bull. Southern California Acad.
Sci.
92(2), 1993, pp. 70-77
© Southern California Academy of Sciences, 1993 |
|
35. |
A PARADE OF ANOMALIES: LEARNING
Pages 111-128. 1990 (Wenner and Wells, Columbia Univ. Press) |
|
36. |
Did Radar Tracking of Bee Flight Paths Resolve
the Bee Language Controversy? |
|
37. |
Odor and honey bee exploitation of food
crops
Third European Congress on
Social Insects
St. Petersburg, Russia,
22-27 August 2005
Abstract for Plenary Lecture |
|
38. |
Resolving a Controversy or Shoring
up a Belief System? |
| 39. |
BREAKTHROUGHS |
| 40. |
The Honey Bee Odor-Search Hypothesis & DNA Genome Analysis
Bee Culture - June,
2007 - Pages 25-26 |
| 41. |
Excursus TEL: Teleology
Anatomy of a Controversy :
Pages 362 - 366 |