Cowan or Gunness???

[Sundance]

I am shopping for an uncapper and would like to hear your valuable opinions on the pros and cons of both the Cowan and Gunness uncappers.

My operation will top out at 500 colonies (hopefully!).

[Trevor Mansell]

Ive had both ,I use a Gunness now . The Gunness requires no heat source. The Gunness is faster but harder on the equipment. The cowen is a nice machine though when set up properly it works great. With you beeing in North Dakota you aregoing to want to run steam into the gunness with the cooler temperatures the wax will get brittle and chip off ,sometimes the foundation will go with it, unless you use plastic.

[Sundance]

Define "cooler".....

My uncapping will be done in a heated shop so temps should not be an issue. And it can get very toasty here in July and August when flows are on.

How is the Gunness hard on equipment.

Thanks Trevor!

[Trevor Mansell]

The Gunness will sometimes chip the edges off the sidebars. Im not sure what temps to be exact. But if the wax gets cold it gets brittle and unless the frame is full it will tear out beeswax foundation. If you use plastic you wont have a problem. With the Gunness you need to have two people and the cowen you dont.

[Sundance]

Ahhhhhhhh the two people is extremely important.

Is the Cowan that much slower?

[swarm_trapper]

We have the cowan i never have run it that fast but they say it can do 60 boxes an hour and i beleive it. I have talked to a few comercial guys around here and they all agree that the gunness is much easier to run but they like the cowen better. So they kinda told me that if i was going to hire people to do the extracting and not be around to get a gunness, if i would be doing the extracing or just be around to help go with the cowen. And yes if your are the only guy extracting definatly go with the cowen, i have heard of one guy running it but he told me it is not fun to be running around the machine all the time lol. Nick

[Sundance]

Thanks Nick and all. Appreciate the insight.

[Bob Harrison]

The older (and first model I believe ) Gunness model fifty is perfect for one person but much slower than the model 200 (belt machine). The model 50 does 3 frames at a time ( has a slide).
The cowan machines are wonderful *when in adjustment* and also ideal for a single person.
I believe their speed might be a bit slower than the gunness & boganschutz.

I bunch of hispanics, a boganschutz and 6 large extractors can turn out record amounts of production. I have seen 40 barrels in a single day.

Beekeeper friends with the 60 frame cowan say not possible with their machine. Not sure with the larger cowan. Maybe others will comment?

The model 200 gunness is tiring for one person to run but is very fast and trouble free for two people.

The Boganchutz is the uncapper of choice of the large operations. I like the speed and cleaness of the cut but hate the air and crap the machine puts in the honey.

Extracting honey (profitably) involves no breakdowns and being able to keep the help from tiring from the boring work.

Many uncappers simply make way too much noise in my opinion. My complaint to the makers has been noise.

I use the gunness because (as Trevor said) lack of heat. Size of my current operation. Also safety as you can stick your hand in the flails of a gunness and not get hurt. I have never had a breakdown with a gunness.

One draw back of the old style cowan uncapper if the height the frame needs lifted to place in the machine( tiring). You also want your extractors (old style) low enough you don't have to lift your arm high to clear the rim.

Give careful thought to the way your honey house is set up. I hate extracting which is why I hire the work done (if possible).

Most honey houses are too small (including mine). Build the honey house to fit the largest size operation you might grow to.

Hive numbers have a way of getting out of control.

Kind of like raising rabbits! Start with a couple and before long you got more rabbits than you can care for!

[Sundance]

Thanks for the great info Bob. I am leaning toward the Cowan because of the one man operation. I like the safety aspect of the Gunness though..... as well as lack of breakdown.

I visited the shop where the Gunness is made. Very small shop on a farmstead. Another warm and fuzzy knowing the bucks go to a "smaller" operator.

[Brian Suchan]

Gunness all the way weve had ours sine 1988 with out any problems. However keep this in mind if you are in Western Dakota your honey is too dry will not work on the gunness.

[Gregg]

Having seen a Cowen uncapper in operation (helped a commercial outfit extract part of one Summer that had a Silver Queen) and having used a Gunness (smaller one, 100 model) for the last 6 years, (also have seen the 200 model in operation as a friend has one), here's my comments:

- no heat required for the Gunness is nice
- helps a lot if the honey is warmed in a hot room prior to uncapping with the Gunness
- a LOT of wax will wind up in honey storage tanks with the Gunness, unless all the honey goes through a spinner first; skimming tanks is a major pain (speaking from experience)
- the Gunness is faster than the Cowen, no doubt about it; however more man power is required
- the Gunness is noisy
- heat is required with the Cowen; issue or not? Cowen makes a self contained hot water heater
- auto load is not possible with the Gunness as with the Cowen; while loading and unloading frames into and out of an extractor is not extremely hard work (some might consider it), it does get old and it is time-consuming.

Summary (IMHO): The Gunness is probably a better machine for a large operation (several thousand hives) with adequate man power and several extractors; the Cowen is probably better suited to a somewhat smaller operation, 1-2 person crew using the auto load.

[Sundance]

Thanks Gregg.........

[SUKIE]

As Brian said buy the Gunness. Probably ran close to a 1000 drum of honey thru our's in the 18 years we have had ours & have spent less than $100 bucks on it total. Yes the 1st year or two it will be hard on side bars & poor equiptment but learn to adjust the cutting depth. We set one side deeper than the other. This with running the frames at an 45 degree angle cures most of the problems.

[livetrappingbymatt]

only have used the dakota gunness but i sure do like the way it works.it does work smoother w/2 people.
bob